Mistaken Identity | Fet Library

Short

Bree A. presents

Mistaken Identity

4.6 (7)

Heavy
Real Life
Bondage

You've started reading this story - want to continue?

When they were young, nobody could tell Gina and Tina apart. They dressed the same, acted the same, even cut their hair identically. One of the favorite tricks the girls pulled was to switch out on people. Gina would go out on a date with some guy and then the next time, it would be Tina who would enjoy a nice time. The trick was to see if the guy ever realized the switch. There were only two things that separated them. Gina was the more adventurous of the two while Tina was more reserved. Also, Gina finally came out to her sister that she was gay. It didn't matter to Tina though. They both loved each other so much that nothing could drive a wedge between them. "Hey Sis," Gina said when she told Tina about her sexuality, "at least I won't be stealing your boyfriend." They both had a good laugh at that.

When they graduated college, Tina married whom she thought was the man of her dreams. It turned out though that he was an abusive womanizer who would fuck any cute skirt that showed even a passing interest. When she found out that he had knocked up another woman, that was the last straw. Tina called her sister, bawling her eyes out and telling Gina everything that had happened. Gina told her to drive down to her place immediately and they would figure this out. So, Tina threw some clothes in a suitcase and left the bastard.

Gina, on the other hand, left home and went to the big city to intern at the best hospital on the coast. There, she met the girl of her dreams, Maria, a lovely, dark skinned latina, who satisfied all of her kinky desires. They had tried it all! Spanking, bondage, a little pain, even water sports. Whatever Maria wanted to do to her, Gina was game. It was such a blast! But when her sister called, crying that her husband was a fucking prick and abuser, she was willing to drop everything to help her.

Maria couldn't believe her luck. Here was this gorgeous blonde slut with a knockout body that was just as kinky as she was! They made a stunning pair. Maria's dark, sultry looks contrasted so nicely with Gina's blonde hair and supermodel body. Gina had even confided in her that one of her biggest, kinkiest fantasies was a rape fantasy where she was attacked and ravaged by a home intruder. Gina had recently given Maria the key to her apartment and tonight, she was going to make her girlfriend's fantasy a reality.

*****************************

Tina arrived at her sister's place to find it empty. A note on the counter told her that Gina had been called into the hospital on an emergency to fill in for one of her coworkers and that she wouldn't be back until tomorrow morning and to make herself at home. It had been a long drive and Tina was not only physically tired but emotionally as well. After grabbing a quick bite from the fridge, she went to her sister's bedroom, stripped to her panties and climbed in bed. She was out almost instantly.

Maria pulled up to the apartment, parked her car and removed the duffle from the back seat. She had packed all of the essentials. Duct tape, handcuffs, a little fold out knife were in the bag as well as the nipple clamps that she knew Gina loved and the new eight inch strap on she had just purchased that day. Maria couldn't wait to fuck her little love toy to the hilt. She parked up the street and made her way to Gina's place. As quietly as she could, Maria unlocked the door and crept inside. There was enough light streaming through the windows that she had no trouble navigating her way to the bedroom.

Maria peeked inside. There she was, her gorgeous girlfriend. The covers had been kicked off and Maria saw that she was sleeping in just her panties. Just the sight of the beautiful blonde and the knowledge of what was about to come caused her pussy to moisten. Finding a pair of Gina's used panties laying on the floor, Maria acted quickly. She crept to the bed and in one swift movement, crammed the panties in the sleeping girls mouth and pressed the tip of the knife against her throat.

Tina's eyes flew open in fear and shock. A hand covered her mouth, preventing her from spitting out the gag and she felt the tip of the knife press against her throat, causing her to freeze with fear. A woman's voice whispered in her ear. "Listen chica! You do exactly as I say and I won't have to hurt you. Much. You try to scream or fight me..." She left the threat hang in the air. Tina felt the sharpened tip press harder against her skin, drawing a drop of blood. "Understand?" Tina nodded, her eyes wide with terror.

Maria pinned her body down. Jesus, this was turning her on so much! Gina genuinely looked afraid! She pinned her girlfriends body down and placed the knife on the nightstand next to the bed. She reached into the duffle bag on the floor and pulled out the tape. Getting a nice long piece, Maria moved her hand and taped the other woman's mouth shut. Just to make sure, she added a couple of more pieces before reaching in the bag for the handcuffs. Her girlfriend started to struggle when Maria tried to lock the cuffs to the bed, forcing her to grab the knife. "HEY!" she said, flashing the blade in front of the other woman's eyes. That eased the struggling and Maria was able to finish locking her woman to the bed. Gina had started crying at this point, turning Maria on even more. Starting at the neck, she trailed the knife blade down her captives body. Over her tits, down her flat stomach, to her panties. A couple of quick slices and the undergarment was removed. Oh God! Maria thought to herself, My baby shaved! She massage the bald lips, feeling her girlfriend up before slipping her finger deep in the pussy hole, tickling her inner wall. She noticed that Gina's breathing quickened the more she fondled her and just before she came, Maria withdrew her hand.

A look of consternation crossed Tina's face and she felt her cheeks flush with embarrassment. This woman almost got her off. Tears were falling down her face onto the pillow and she watched her captor begin to strip off her clothes. Despite the fear she was feeling, Tina couldn't help but be a little turned on, her pussy betraying her by getting wet and almost cumming from the stimulation. She was even a little disappointed that the other woman hadn't finished. But her eyes got big again and she started to shake her head no as she saw what the lady had pulled out of the bag.

Maria started working over her girlfriend's nipples, pinching, twisting and pulling to get them rock hard for the set of clover clamps that she had brought. She couldn't resist those luscious nipples and leaned down to get a taste. Hearing Gina moan into the gag made her smile and stop licking. She pinched the right nipple between her fingers and applied the clamp. The blonde squealed in pain as Maria did the same thing to the other one. Gina's breasts were heaving, causing the clamps to jiggle. Maria leaned down, whispering in her captive's ear. "Oh baby! If you like that, you are going to LOVE this!" She bit the earlobe gently, raised up and reached into the bag, pulling out the strap on.

Tina couldn't believe her eyes as the other woman strapped that monster in place on her crotch. She had never been fucked by something that large. The pain in her nipples was mellowing out to a dull ache and her jaw was beginning to hurt from her being unable to close it. She closed her eyes, praying that this was all a nightmare. But her eyes flew open again when she felt the other woman's mouth on her quim.

Maria began to lick the bald pussy, enjoying the taste of the cum that had leaked out. She always had prided herself on her pussy eating techniques. Several former girlfriends still came around just to get Maria to get them off, she was that good. Soon, she had her little chica's body writhing in lust as she ate the girl until cum flooded her mouth. That's when Maria climbed up on the bed, positioned the plastic prick at her captive's waiting hole and pushed in to the hilt with one strong thrust. She began to fuck the blonde underneath her, picking up the pace as she found her rhythm.

OH FUCK! Tina thought to herself, wildly. After the pleasure that the woman gave her, Tina was ready for the fucking from the dildo. But this was nothing she had experienced, even with her husband. She began pulling and struggling against the bonds, not so much to get free but to wrap her arms around this lady and pull her closer. Tina felt an orgasm beginning to swell again as the relentless pounding of her pussy drove her closer to climax. The pain in her nipples, the fear she had felt and the pleasure she was receiving now drove her over the edge and she nearly passed out from the power of the cumming she experienced.

The little nub at the base of the dildo was rubbing Maria's clit just right with every thrust and she to climaxed just as her girlfriend screamed, this time with pleasure as the orgasm she gave Gina caused her to start cumming too. They both froze as the waves crashed over each woman. At last, she and Gina came down from the high. It was almost time for round two Maria thought to herself. She climbed off the panting girl, the dildo slick with cum, when she noticed that her phone registered that she had a message. She was about to ignore it when something caused her to pause. Picking up the phone, Maria noticed that she had missed a call. From Gina. Quickly pressing the message icon, Maria heard her girlfriend's voice come over the speaker.

"Hey girl. Just wanted to let you know that I had to be called in to work tonight. Sorry about not letting you know but this is my first break. Hey, my sister Tina is coming into town sometime tonight. She had a real tough time of it. Maybe you should go to see her and introduce yourself. I'm sure she would be happy to meet you."

When Maria checked the message, she quickly figured out what had happened. She turned on the light to the bedroom and, as fast as she could, began to undo Tina from her bindings. First, removing the nipple clamps and then the gag, she started unlocking the handcuffs, apologizing profusely in English and Spanish.

Tina, who was still crying, reached up and hugged Maria in a deep embrace as soon as her arms were free. It had been such an emotional day that she had to release all of the conflicting feelings that had built up in her body. The anger of Johnny cheating on her, the frustration that she felt as she thought she had wasted her life with him, the fear of the attack, the pleasure that she felt with the orgasms, and the guilt that was in her because she felt dirty from feeling that pleasure. Maria let her cry, still feeling awful about what had happened, knowing that Tina needed to let it all out. She gently laid the still sobbing woman on the bed and went to the bathroom and ran a nice, hot bubble bath for her. When she came back, Maria had helped the woman up and led her to the tub. Tina gratefully sank into the steaming water, feeling the tension leave her body. After her mind had cleared, she started laughing about the situation and the look on Maria's face when she had the dawning moment of realization.

Maria, who was sitting on the toilet, began to worry that Tina was cracking up until Tina told her what she had found so funny. Then Maria couldn't help but join in. She asked Tina if she should leave and was told a firm no. Both had to be there for Gina in the morning. After a fitful night's sleep, Tina gave up getting rested and went to make coffee and breakfast for everyone.

Gina had come home from the hospital to find her girlfriend and her sister sitting at the kitchen table, sipping coffee. She knew right away that something had happened when Tina blushed and wouldn't make eye contact. Maria, who was fearless when it came to confrontations, told Gina the whole story. How she had wanted to give Gina a chance to live out her fantasy, how she executed the whole scenario, even how Tina had orgasmed twice from Maria's expert techniques. Tina blushed again at that last part.

"Oh Tina! I am so sorry!"

"It's alright sis." Tina said, smiling. "Maria and I talked about it. It was an honest mistake."

Gina couldn't believe what had happened after hearing all that had transpired. She wasn't angry with her sister who was innocent of duplicity and couldn't be angry with Maria because it had been an honest mistake. After all, Maria was just trying to make her fantasy a reality. She was most upset with herself because, after hearing it, she was turned on. She quickly changed the subject to Tina's issue with her husband.

Tina's eyes hardened as she told the two women how she had stumbled on the secret file on the computer. It seemed that Johnny loved to take pictures of all of his "conquests" and that he had accidentally gotten one of the ladies pregnant. He was heavily leaning on the lady to get an abortion, going so far as to threaten her with violence if she didn't abort the baby. She confronted him about it when he had gotten hold of work. Instead of feeling guilt or even trying to deny it, he had just laughed, telling her that she honestly didn't expect him to stop and that she wasn't that good of a fuck. "You can't give me what I want bitch, so I have to go out and get it." he had said when she told him she knew.

"God! I'm such a fucking idiot!" Tina said with anger tinged with sadness. "I knew he liked to flirt and suspected he fooled around a little. But, when I saw all of the pictures, I couldn't take it anymore." She began to cry again and Gina got up to hug her sister, holding her tightly as Tina sobbed on her shoulder.

"It's gonna be alright, Sis. You know you have to leave him." Gina said, still holding on to her sister's shoulders. Tina nodded and pulled back, taking another sip of coffee. Her eyes were red from crying and Gina's were narrowed with anger.

Maria had been sitting there, listening to the whole sordid tale. She was just as angry at Johnny as her lover was. He had caused Tina a lot of pain and in doing so had upset her lover as well. Damn him! she thought to herself. That fucker has to pay! And not just with money. If it wasn't for him, none of what happened last night would have occurred. That's when an idea struck her. "Hey ladies. I have an idea that I think you two will like to hear." Both women looked at the lovely latina. "Why don't we give him a taste of his own medicine." Maria laid out her plan and, when she was finished, looked at both of them to judge their reactions. It was eerie how both had the same devilish smile on their faces. This was going to be fun.

Maria laid out her idea to which both sisters laughed and readily agreed. She would have to leave for a while to pick up a few things but would be back to put the plan into action. Gina, who was exhausted by all that had happened, not to mention just getting off of work, got up, kissed her girlfriend deeply and went to prepare herself to get some sleep. Maria rose next and as she walked by, patted Tina reassuredly on the shoulder and left the apartment leaving Tina sitting alone at the kitchen table, sipping her coffee.

The events of the past day kept playing in her mind. Finding the file on the computer only confirmed what she knew in her heart but didn't want to believe. She had long suspected Johnny was cheating on her but instead of confronting him about it, she ignored it and played the dutiful wife. She began to wonder why he had strayed so much. Was it like he said? That she wasn't good enough in bed? She tried to satisfy him as best she could. Looking back at the last several sexual sessions she had with him, though, it seemed that all he did was fuck her, get his rocks off and then either leave for work or just go to sleep. Tina couldn't recall the last time that she had achieved an orgasm just from sex. Until last night. The memories of what Maria had done to her caused Tina to clench her thighs together and her clit to start tingling again. Yes, the fear had been there but the sex, from Maria eating her out to being pounded by the fake cock, had been the most exhilarating encounter that she had ever had. Even the nipple clamps and tasting the panties that had been stuffed in her mouth caused fresh tinglings to travel though her body.

Tina closed her eyes, feeling her nipples hardening under her tee shirt. She pulled her shirt up and started to gently massage her breasts and tweak her nipples as the other hand snaked down and went under the waistband of her panties. In her minds eye, she could picture Maria fucking her, slamming the strap on deep within her pussy as she was handcuffed to the bed. Tina began to feel herself getting moist again as the memories of what happened caused her to bury two fingers deep in her hole. She leaned back in the chair, her legs splayed out before her as, in her mind, she was a willing participant this time, knowing full well who was fucking her, knowing that it was a beautiful woman that had caused her so much pleasure. She began to pinch her nipples, gently at first, but then getting more aggressive, twisting and pulling them, digging her nails in as the other hand was tickling her inner walls. She used her thumb to rub her clitty, scraping the sensitive nubbin with her nail as she felt the orgasm getting closer. Then she remembered the mind blowing orgasm that Maria had given her as the head of the dildo slammed against her cervix. That did it. Tina clenched down and cried out as she brought herself off. All of her muscles froze as her juices coated her fingers. After a few moments, her breathing relaxed and when she opened her eyes, Tina was shocked and embarrassed to see her sister standing at the entrance to the kitchen, smiling at the sight before her.

Gina couldn't help herself but laugh at her twin's expression. "Well, sis. I was going to tell you good night and everything will be alright but I can see that you are recovering nicely."

"I'm...oh God Gina! I'm so sorry!" Tina quickly removed her hand from under her panties. They were sticky from her cum, glistening under the kitchen lights.

"No need to apologize sis. It was Maria, wasn't it?" Gina said, guessing correctly what had caused her twin to cum so fiercely. Tina closed her eyes in shame, nodding her head. Gina came over and hugged her sister, kissing her gently on the forehead. She knelt down, looking Tina directly in the eyes. "Hey sis. There's nothing to be ashamed of. It was a new experience and the shock of all that happened is probably what did it. It doesn't mean that you are gay."

"I know Gee." Tina whispered. "But...I want to do it again. It was...just amazing. I never had such an orgasm from Johnny or any other man."

Gina giggled. "Well sis. Then we need to find you a good woman, then! And, no, you can't have mine." A small laugh escaped from Tina's lips as she hugged her sister again, being careful not to wipe any of the sticky goo onto Gina's night shirt. "Now, I have to get some sleep. We have a busy night ahead of us." Gina stood up and walked out of the kitchen. Tina watched her sister leave, her eyes trailing down to her ass, barely covered in sheer panties. Then she looked at her fingers, studying them intently. She brought them to her lips and began to delicately lick them clean, enjoying the taste of her own cum.

****************************************

The trip back to Tina's house took about four hours. Maria had been gone most of the day, getting a few supplies that she had kept hidden from the twins. On the way up, they all had discussed Tina's newly discovered desires as well as what was going to happen that night. Gina and Maria had to work hard to keep Tina's mind firmly on the plan. She had begun having second thought about getting revenge on Johnny, her own self doubts that he had implanted in her coming to the forefront. But the other two were firm in their conviction. Gina was so angry at him for what he had done to Tina. Not only the infidelity but also trying to crush her spirit. They weren't going to do any lasting damage to him, she assured her sister. Just teach him a valuable lesson.

Maria had been in the backseat of the car, watching the two sisters interact with each other. It was an amazing sight to see. An almost living mirror as the twins would brush their hair back at the exact same time, scratch the same itch. Even move in sync, all without thinking. She had genuinely felt bad about what she had done to Tina but had recognized her reactions when Tina had orgasmed. The woman had loved what Maria had done to her.

The three pulled onto the street where Tina had lived and passed the house just as the door opened. Tina was shocked to see Debra Morgan, her next door neighbor, walk out of the door and back to her house. Tina knew that Ron, her husband, wasn't home, being away on business. The sight steeled her resolve again. Her eyes narrowed in anger and the other two had to stop her from getting out of the car right then to confront the other woman.

They drove up the block and parked at the playground. Tina knew that Johnny would be asleep by eleven. Any doubts about what was going to happen had long since evaporated as her nipples hardened in excitement at what they were planning to do. She drove them back to her house. All the lights were off as they pulled up and parked under the car port. Entering through the side entrance, Tina led them quietly to the bedroom. The sound of Johnny's snoring greeted them as well as the faint but lingering scent of perfume. Tina nodded to Maria who was carrying her pocket knife as well as the duffle bag containing all of the goodies.

At her signal, Maria pulled out the same panties that she had used last night on Tina from her pocket. She silently walked up to the sleeping man and in one swift moment, gagged him and pressed the tip of the knife to his throat. The sisters each grabbed one of his arms as his eyes flew open in shock. "Listen bendejo, you are going to lay right there. Understand?" She pressed the knife in and twisted it just a bit but enough to prick his skin. He nodded, fear in his eyes, and the two sisters each took a pair of handcuffs that they had been holding and locked him to the bed. Then, they did the same to his ankles. Maria had to buy a special pair of cuffs to make sure that they would fit around his feet properly. When he was locked up tight, Tina took the duct tape and put a piece over his eyes, blindfolding him and then she taped his mouth shut with several more pieces. Only then did Maria remove the knife from his throat.

Johnny was breathing heavily through his nostrils, his chest heaving in fear as he felt the tip of the knife drag down his body, Then the sound of cutting fabric reached his ears as Maria made quick work of his boxers. All three women laughed at the sight at his penis, which had shriveled up in fear. Maria reached down into the bag on the floor and pulled out her little secret that she had been hiding from the twins. She grabbed his balls tightly, squeezing them as a moan of pain emanated from behind the gag. "You like fucking women so much with your little prick here? Well, no more." She locked on the pink cock cage that she had purchased earlier. Gina and Maria laughed at what had just transpired and even Tina couldn't help but join in after the shock wore off. "No more fucking for you for a long while, chica." Maria said, flicking his balls with her finger.

Next, she reached in the bag again and brought out the clover clamps. Pinching his nipple hard between her fingers, Maria applied the clamps bringing out a fresh moan of pain. She reached into the duffle one more time and brought out the strap on as well as a jar and a tube. Turning to Tina, Maria nodded at the girl. Tina took a deep breath and removed her shoes, jeans and panties. Maria helped her buckle the strap on to her waist and then coated the dildo with the cream from the tube. The strong scent of peppermint wafted to Tina's nose and her eyes widened in realization that the lovely latina had just applied Ben Gay all over the plastic phallus. Maria and Gina each undid one of Johnny's legs and pulled them up over his head, exposing his asshole to his wife. Locking him down again, Maria grabbed the tube of cream and squeezed out a large dollop right on his ball sack. She rubbed it into his skin, squeezing it hard as the burning started. Johnny began to cry from behind the gag as the burning in his balls began. Not finished yet, Maria then undid the cap on the jalapeno hot sauce and doused the head of his dick liberally through the opening of the chastity device.

He really started bawling then and Tina almost lost her nerve. But the image of her neighbor coming out of the house drove her to climb up on her bed and slam the dildo deep in his ass. All of the months of verbal abuse, all of the images of the women he fucked went through her mind as she began to not to gently fuck him. A little tentative at first, Tina picked up speed as the enthusiasm to fuck him the way he never did her inspired her. The little nub at the base of the dildo rubbed her clit, causing her to gasp in pleasure as she slammed her hips as hard as she could.

Johnny had never been in so much pain. The burning in his ass and genitals and the crushing clamps on his nipples finally were driving him crazy. At last, Tina got off from fucking him. He felt the dildo buried in his ass still as the sound of the buckles being undone broke through his pain fogged mind. The tape was unceremoniously ripped from his eyes, taking a good bit of his eyebrows with it. His sight adjusted to the blinding light and he started screaming into his gag as he saw his wife, sister in law and the Latin bitch that had threatened him standing there.

"Oh don't worry honey." Tina said in her sweetest voice. "We'll just leave the key to the handcuffs in Debra's mailbox as well as a note explaining how you are a bit, well, tied up. Oh, and the key to this?" she added, gripping the cock lock and shaking it for emphasis. "Well, I'm just going to mail the key to your mother as well as a nice note explaining how her son is a little prick with a little prick. You can call her and ask for it nicely if you want. Oh. if you are planning on calling the cops on me, I will make sure that all the pictures we just took as well as a copy of the file on your computer showing all of your conquests go out to all your friends as well as business clients. I'm sure that they will be so interested in knowing that they are dealing with a womanizing piece of shit. Expect a call from my attorney."

With that, the girls removed the dildo and clamps as well as the leg restraints from his ankles, leaving Johnny locked to the bed with burning balls, crying into his gag.

© 2018 Bree A. · All rights reserved

Bree A. took the time to write this, and our authors really appreciate feedback — please take a moment to rate and review Mistaken Identity.

Tap a star to rate

You might also like

Browse more ->

Short

A harmless roleplay session between a husband and wife. Honest. Don't worry about the story tags, I probably just misclicked.

5.0

Short

A decadent banquet. Eve wears torturous attire as she and Moldred meet for the first time.

5.0

Short

After the great cultural revolution colloquially called the Great Female Takeover, the world looks like quite a different place. The military included. As one particularly hot young prisoner of war is about to find out. . .

5.0