Surprise Party

Jim and Jake threw the best surprise parties.

The guests of honor this time were certainly surprised, shrieking with joy when they saw the boys jump out from behind a couch.  After all, most surprise parties are at least a little predictable: they fall on something like a birthday or anniversary, they involve one's friends and family, and so on.  No one expects to come home on a random Friday night to find two naked strangers ready for some good times.

In a rare turnaround, even Jim and Jake were surprised!  They’d expected to be throwing their party for a boy and a girl, which was never ideal; three boys were a crowd.  To their delight, both of their new friends were girls.  The boys considered themselves very progressive, and were enthusiastic supporters of lesbians in particular.  There were so many fun games to share with them.

But before that, it was good to get to know each other a little.  Jim herded the two excited girls into the living room, and Jake brought them the first of many party favors: a pair of friendship bracelets for the both of them.  They helped the girls put them on, bringing their wrists behind their backs and snapping the metal jewelry in place.

The bracelets looked beautiful on them, but they clashed terribly with all the clothes they had on, so Jake helpfully drew his hunting knife and sliced the offending garments away.  The girls kept very still, clearly impressed by his ability to only nick them occasionally.

Once that was taken care of, they split up for some one-on-one chats.  Jim chose the leggy brunette, whom he’d decided to nickname Cumrag.  He sat on the loveseat and pulled her into his lap, facing him, so he could get to know her tits a little better.  After a bit of groping and tasting, he judged them to be excellent, and told her they would be a perfect fit around his dick.  Cumrag said nothing at first, but after a playful nipple pinch, she remembered her manners and thanked him for the compliment.

Jake’s redheaded partner, nicknamed Red Meat after her bushy pussy, was facedown on the couch.  Jake rested comfortably on top of her, mouth by her ear, whispering all the fun ideas he had for her sexy body.  Shivering, possibly from the cold, Red Meat agreed that these all sounded great.  He shifted position slightly to let her stroke his dick with her fingers, whispering about how well she was going to get to know it before the party was over.

The first game began about an hour in.  It had taken some time to get Cumrag and Red Meat into the right festive spirit, but once they fully understood the situation, they turned into regular party animals.  As it happened, neither of them had ever played the sort of games that only a boy and girl can play together, so Jim and Jake were going to have their hands full helping them catch up.

They started with a little favorite of the boys’ called Hide The Sausage.  The girls competed to see who could be first to swallow one of the boy’s cocks all the way down their throats and win herself a shiny party point.

Party points were like the scoreboard for the party.  As Jim and Jake had explained to their rapt audience, they’d come prepared to usher the singular guest of honor away to an indefinite vacation at the party’s conclusion.  Now that they had two to deal with, things were a little more complicated.  The only sensible course of action, then, was to keep one and kill the other.

Both girls had gone very pale when Jake brought up the K word, but Jim did his best to calm them down.  He told them that rather than think of their situation as “whoever gets least points dies”, it was better to be optimistic and think “whoever gets the most points lives”.

The girls had agreed that the glass half-full approach definitely made a difference.

Jim and Jake sat side by side on the couch, cocks pointing directly at the ceiling, while the girls knelt in front of them with their heads in their laps, trying to gobble up their meaty treat.  They both seemed very determined to win, coughing, gagging, and retching as they battled their own gag reflexes for victory.  At the end of a pitched fight, it was Red Meat who managed it first, burying her nose into Jake’s pubes.  Her reward was sucking her throat slime off his prick, and then settling into a slow, sloppy blowjob.  Meanwhile, Jim gave Cumrag some pointers for the next time she played a game like this, bouncing her head up and down his shaft to demonstrate proper technique.  Eventually both girls received their own all natural protein drink, which they gulped down.

The next game was called Pussy Paddling.  Standing at the foot of their bed, both girls bent over, legs spread wide.  Their hands, friendship bracelets still jangling on them, reached back to pull their labia apart.  The game came with its own special song, both fun and informative, which they sang in unison:

Please paddle my pussy, master,
Give it all you’ve got!
And when I can’t take anymore,
Please stuff my hungry twat!

The boys happily played their part, smashing the exposed slits with thin wooden paddles.  They gave the girls a few moments to stop screaming, then prompted them to sing again.

Both girls proved to have deep competitive streaks in them.  After ten hits, their pussies were bruised and swollen, but they kept singing.  By twenty, the verses were barely intelligible through the blubbering, but they kept coming.  It wasn’t until number twenty seven that Red Meat ran out of steam, unable to ask for another paddling.

Jake wasted no time fulfilling the second part of the song, cramming his rock hard dick into her.  He knew this was the first time she’d done this with a man, and he was determined to make it memorable for her.

Jim, on the other hand, offered Cumrag a bonus round: if she made it through another five hits, he’d leave her pussy untouched.  The brunette agreed, and endured one, two, three hard smacks from the paddle.  As she awaited the fourth, she was caught completely by surprise when he grabbed her by the hips and thrust himself into her instead.

Laughing at the prank he’d just pulled, Jim explained to his somewhat miffed friend that he'd only promised to stop if she made it through five more hits; he never technically promised to give her those five hits in the first place.  Cumrag didn’t seem impressed at first, but after a little encouragement she admitted that it was a very good prank that he’d played on her, and that it was after all wonderful to have him inside her.

A few hours into the party, Jim and Jake had now made excellent progress giving their friends a crash course on playing with boys.  The girls still had one inexperienced hole left, but the boys had saved the favorite for last, and they knew just the right game for it: Anal Auction.

The idea was fairly simple.  The girls were going to auction off their asses, taking turns making suggestions about how the boys could have even more fun playing with them.  Each suggestion would incorporate all the past ones, unless it directly countered one, until neither girl was willing or able to think of a better way to get their assholes fucked.  Both girls would get to enjoy the full experience, of course, but only one would earn the party point for it.

Before they got started, Jim and Jake made sure their friends knew that this was going to be their very last chance to earn points.  They were tied, so the result of this game would literally mean life or death.  Jake brought out his hunting knife again, and slowly ran it back and forth over their throats, while the girls quivered with anticipation.

The game went something like this.  The actual bidding process took hours, and involved lots of crying, stuttering, and suggestions that the boys rejected.  The streamlined version:

Red Meat suggested they do it face up, legs in the air, so the boys could watch their expressions while they were being used.

Cumrag suggested that they use some duct tape to tape them into the position.

Red Meat suggested that zip ties would hurt more.

Cumrag suggested that while they were at it, they fasten more zip ties around their base of their tits to make them bigger.

Red Meat suggested they stick a dildo in their cunts, to make their assholes extra tight.

Cumrag suggested the dildo be coated in hot sauce, so that they would never stop squirming (this one drew an approving whistle from the boys).

Red Meat suggested they tape their cunts closed, and leave the dildos in all night afterwards.

Cumrag suggested whipping their anus before beginning, to make it swell up.

Red Meat suggested they get whipped five times.

Cumrag suggested ten.

Red Meat suggested fifteen.

Cumrag suggested Jim and Jake whip them however many times they liked, until they were ready to get started (this ended up being eighty four).

Red Meat suggested they should smile the whole time, or else get their cunt smacked until they behaved (Jim asked her why she wouldn't naturally be smiling all the time during such a fun game, and chuckled when she adorably couldn't come up with an answer).

Cumrag countered that they should wear nipple clamps instead, with a chain that the boys could tug on when they stopped smiling.

Red Meat countered that the clamps might fall off, and suggested chained nipple piercings instead.  This was accepted, but Jake noted that she already had pierced nipples, and the boys unilaterally decided it should be a clit piercing with a leash instead.

Cumrag suggested the boys tug on their clit leashes every time they wanted the girls to clench their butts.

Red Meat countered that they should be clenching in rhythm anyway, and only tugged when they stop.

Cumrag suggested they clean the boys’ cocks afterwards.

Red Meat countered that their wives should be the one to handle the cock cleaning.

Cumrag suggested that if the cleaning got the boys hard again, they should go another round.

Red Meat suggested Jim and Jake keep going like that until their balls were literally too drained to continue.

Cumrag suggested butt plugs afterwards, so they could spend the night with a cum enema.

Red Meat suggested that the entire experience be filmed.

Cumrag suggested there be a section at the beginning and end where the girls pretended agreed this was entirely consensual.

Red Meat suggested they post the video to their social media, scheduled for release right after the party ended.

Cumrag suggested they send a link and personalized note to everyone they knew, imploring them to watch.

There was a long break at this point, where Red Meat tried and failed to get numerous suggestions through.  At the end of her rope, inspired by the Pussy Paddling game they'd played earlier, she tossed out a final Hail Mary: a song.  The four of them would put their heads together and come up with a song that the girls could sing while they were going at it.

The boys loved the idea, and immediately started brainstorming lyrics.  Cumrag hesitantly tried making another suggestion, but she was shot down.  Jim and Jake had gotten their fill out of Anal Auction, and now it was time to move on.  The brunette started to wail as the boys went to find a notepad.

All that was just Friday night.

The next morning, Jim and Jake woke their friends up to resume the games.  When the girls meekly reminded them about last night being the last chance to earn points, the boys claimed not to remember.  And the games continued.

Cumrag earned a point for stuffing the most ice cubes up her cunt.

Red Meat earned one for attaching the most clothespins to her nipples.

Cumrag earned three for finishing her dog food breakfast first.

Red Meat earned two for fitting her entire fist up her ass.

Cumrag earned another five for suggesting Jim and Jake try fucking Red Meat's pussy before letting her remove the fist.

Red Meat got four and a half for reminding Jim that he hadn't titfucked her wife yet.

Cumrag earned one for telling them about Red Meat's fear of drowning, and another nine for telling them about the large tub in the upstairs bathroom they could play with.

The party points came by fast and furious.  Sometimes the boys changed their mind, retroactively adding or subtracting points for past actions.  Sometimes they had a better idea for a different game, or had so much fun that they forgot about the competition entirely.

By the time Sunday night rolled around, neither girl had any idea how many points either of them had.  But they were both in the finest of party spirits, and were willing to do anything for them.

Red Meat tried to get points by telling the boys about how pretty Cumrag's sister was, and how easy it would be to get her somewhere alone with Red's help.

Cumrag tried to get points by offering to kill her wife herself.

Jim and Jake were, to be honest, pretty exhausted at that point.  They'd played just about every game they knew, and made up a dozen more in the spur of the moment.  But seeing how fired up the girls were about their party, all the ideas they were coming up with for last minute points, that enthusiasm infected them too.  A revived Jim eagerly clapped them both on the shoulder as he finally got to announce the results.

The real party points, he told them, had been the friends they made along the way.

The girls stood flabbergasted as the boys lost all composure and laughed themselves silly.  They'd never actually planned to kill either of them.  Good friends were hard to come by, and even popular folks like Jim and Jake weren't going to go waste one.  They'd just wanted a way to encourage the girls, and get them invested in all the fun games they were playing.  And it had worked beautifully.  That was the ticket to a truly excellent surprise party: the surprise.

Tears rolled down the girls' cheeks as they agreed that it had been a very good surprise.

And then it was transportation time.  Jake had gotten in touch with a buyer who was interested in two new playmates, and willing to have them dropped off immediately.  Cumrag obediently swallowed one half of a double ended dildo, her gag reflex long erased by now, and eased the other end into Red Meat's cunt.  Her wife did the same thing, and then the boys bundled them up with ropes, mindful of the bumpy ride ahead with their old car.  It was going to be a seven hour ride, so they also generously inserted vibrators in the girls' ass to help ease their boredom.  Jim quipped that whoever came the least during the ride would get axe murdered at their destination, and then laughed at his own joke.

They drove off into the night.

The video did eventually end up being released.  It was quickly removed for obscenity, of course, but not before racking up thousands of views and being saved locally by hundreds.  It occasionally popped up in various porn streaming sites, never staying for long before being flagged and removed for “real rape”.

Because it was the last time either girl was seen by society at large, the police later reviewed a copy of it for clues during the missing persons investigation.  Some of the detectives discreetly brought additional copies home to rewatch in private.  For research.

It eventually found a home in some of the darker parts of the web, and even spawned a few memes there.  A cropped screenshot of the girls’ gruesomely forced smiles became a reaction image that made it all the way into the mainstream, and some of the song lyrics lived on as inside jokes for years in certain communities.

The full run time was three hours and forty six minutes.  This included a fifteen minute intro where the girls, fully clothed and lacking their friendship bracelets, performed a strip tease and then assisted the boys in getting set up.  They even installed their own clit piercings, telling the camera how much they'd always wanted one.

There was also a five minute outro where the girls talked about how many times they came and thanked the boys profusely.  At one point, they go in to try and kiss the boys on the cheek, causing them to flinch away in disgust.  Jake tells them that no one in the world would want a kiss from an “anal slut with shit breath”.  The video fades to black as the laughing girls agree that they’re just a pair of disgusting, cock obsessed perverts, and no one could ever love them.

The bulk of the video is, of course, the six rounds of hardcore anal action, performed exactly as agreed upon.   Bound in place, with zipped breasts looking like purple balloons.    Puffy, bruised anuses that start out looking more like asterisks than starfish, and end up looking like exit wounds.  Duct taped pussies that make the girls wiggle and shake and jiggle those pretty purple balloon tits.  Little red leashes dangling from their bloodied clits, which the boys repeatedly yank like they're trying to start a lawn mower at any hint of slacking.

And when they’re not busy sucking or screaming, Cumrag and Red Meat spend three hours smiling into the camera and singing the song they'd all come up with, while the boys happily pump away between their thighs.

There's not much of a melody to it, but the lyrics go like this.

We’re just a pair of pretty fucktoys
Getting pounded in the butt!
Being tortured, bound, and shamed,
Just to help some strangers nut!

Thought we’d never touch a dick,
Thought we’d never be such sluts!
Now we spread our legs and smile
With hot man meat in our guts!

And when our new best friends are done
Filling our backdoors with jizz,
They’ll force feed me my wife’s shit!
Maybe even take a whiz!

This is too much fun to stop!
We have finally seen the light!
All it took to take to cock
Was these men to fuck us right!

So it’s bye to our old lives,
To our family and friends!
This is all we're good for now!
This is where our story ends!

And to everybody watching,
Those who wonder where we’ve gone,
Please don’t waste a second mourning!
Our fate's not worth dwelling on!

We've found our true life's purpose,
Our only worth is this:
To be a mouth, a pussy, and an ass,
Attached to some nice tits!

Now if you really want to know
What our future has in store!
Think of what we’re doing now
And just add more and more and more!

And if you still can't understand,
If you find our words bizarre,
All we can do is say again,
What we learned we really are!

We’re just a pair of pretty fucktoys
Getting pounded in the butt!
Being tortured, bound, and shamed,
Just to help some strangers nut...