New Baby for the cheerleader captain - Chapter 4 | Fet Library

Novella

PetPanna presents

New Baby for the cheerleader captain

3.9 (8)

Cheerleaders
Dominance
Submission

Chapter 4 of 4

One last choice

Megan touched the front of my diaper.There was a tiny wet spot on it.

“That’s not enough yet, sweetie your diaper can hold a lot more!” She laughed and picked me up. We went down to the living room where the other girls were chatting and watching TV. Megan sat me down on the couch and started talking to the rest of the team. I listened as they talked about the boys and the upcoming competitions, as if I weren’t even there. It was a familiar feeling; this had happened to me countless times before. Deep down, I wanted their attention and to be part of the team too.I knew what I had to do.

“Gu gaa gu gaaa!” I couldn’t believe I did that! Suddenly, the room fell silent. Megan slowly turned toward me with a big smile on her face.

“Oh, I almost forgot. Girls, I taught… our little girl how to talk!” The other girls giggled and quickly rushed over to pet me.

“Good little girl, maybe one day you’ll learn how to talk,” they said while all eyes were on me, just as I’d wanted. I was a little embarrassed, but their attention felt good. Megan then said,

“You know what, girls? It’s time we gave our little girl a name!” The other girls cheered in agreement. I looked up at them, confused.

“What’s wrong with my real name? Why don’t they call me that?” I thought to myself.

“Ellie! … Brooke! … Lucy!” the girls shouted. After ten minutes of discussion, they decided that my new name would be Haley from now on!

“Great! Do you like your new name, baby Haley?” I looked up at the girls with a red face. I couldn’t believe that none of them knew my real name. Although the little baby they’d turned me into wasn’t really me either. Maybe this new name fits me better now.

“Gaa guu gaaa.” The girls giggled.

“Looks like she likes her new name,” Megan said. She hugged me, and we watched TV together all afternoon. The other girls slowly left the room; some had other things to do some ran off to see their boyfriends, others went to the gym. Only Megan and I were left in the living room. As she stroked my hair, I slowly found myself lying in her lap, and I almost fell asleep.

When I opened my eyes, I was already in my crib. I couldn’t remember who had brought me to the nursery or when. After a little while, I fell back asleep. In the morning, when I woke up, I noticed my diaper was a little wet. I tried to hold it in, but Megan’s words came to mind, and it already smelled a little bad anyway. I started peeing until the diaper was completely soaked. I could feel it rubbing against my skin with every movement and how heavy it had become from all the pee.

I looked up at the door and waited for Megan to open it and change my diaper. But she didn’t come. I’d been lying in my dirty diaper for two hours now, and I was starting to feel hungry. I took the pacifier out of my mouth and started talking in baby talk, hoping someone would hear me.

“Gu gaa guu ga” But no one came. I started to panic that they’d forgotten me! I remembered an unpleasant memory of when my parents left me at a gas station and came back for me two hours later. As I thought about this, I started crying and remembered what Megan had said. That I have to call her "Mommy." Maybe she won't come in because she's waiting for me to call her "Mommy." I was so desperate that I didn't care how humiliating it would be—I just wanted her to change my diaper! I started screaming as loud as I could.

“Mommy! Mommy… Mommy!!” After a little while, the door opened and one of the girls walked in. I think her name was Becky. She slowly walked over to my crib.

“Oh, poor thing! Haley, your mommy isn’t here right now she had to go. But Auntie Becky is here to help.” She lowered the rail of my crib and took my hand.

“Come on, sit on the changing table.” With tears in my eyes, I took her hand and followed her to the changing table.

“You know, not everyone is as strong as your mommy. I can’t lift you up.” Becky unwrapped my diaper and put a clean one on me. When we were done, she wiped my face and put my pacifier back in my mouth.

We went down to the kitchen together, and she sat me in the high chair. Once I calmed down, I saw that there were only a few girls left in the house. The other two didn’t even pay attention to me. Becky brought a full bottle and put it in my mouth. I started sucking immediately because I was very hungry. After I finished three baby bottles, I heard the door open. Half the team rushed in, including Megan, who was crying!

“I can’t believe he did this to me!”

“Don’t worry about it, Megan. He didn’t deserve you!” the girls said as they tried to calm Megan. One of the girls came over to Becky.

“Thomas cheated on Megan! She caught him this morning with that slut Amanda from the purple team.” Becky put down my baby bottle and said,

“I can’t believe it! Poor Megan!”

Megan hadn't even looked at me all afternoon, and the other girls weren't paying any attention to me either. I'd been sitting there strapped into my high chair since breakfast. The whole group was trying to comfort Megan, who just kept crying. My legs were already starting to go numb when I felt... I felt like I had to pee! It was one thing to pee in front of Megan, but I’d never peed in front of the whole team before. Luckily, they weren’t paying attention to me.

Maybe if I peed now, they wouldn’t notice until we got to my nursery. I closed my eyes and started to pee. I felt like everything was going well, and when I was done, I opened my eyes and... The whole team was standing there in front of me, with Megan at the front. She slowly wiped the tears from her eyes and said,

“Haley, sweetie!” Tears slowly came to my eyes because I’d humiliated myself so much in front of everyone.

“Don’t cry, Haley. Mommy’s here and she’ll take care of you!” Megan took me out of the high chair and carried me up to my nursery. When we got there, she sat me down on the changing table and started unwrapping my wet diaper. She tried to wipe away her own tears and clean me up at the same time. When she was done, she sat down on the playmat and pulled me onto her lap. A warm, safe feeling came over me.

Megan smiled down at me with teary eyes. I felt sorry for what had happened to her; I was just about to take the pacifier out of my mouth to tell her that... But then she pushed the pacifier back into my mouth and shook her head.

“Remember the rules, Haley. Just because Mommy’s sad doesn’t mean the rules don’t apply to you.” I swallowed as the rubber nipple slid back into my mouth.

“You know, sweetie, something really bad happened to Mommy today, and it seemed like nothing could help me. But then Becky told me what happened this morning. That you called me ‘Mommy’ and cried for me.” I looked back at her, embarrassed.

“I was so happy to hear that you can’t even imagine how much. From that moment on, I wasn’t dwelling on Thomas cheating on me; I was just happy that you’re my little girl, Haley.” Megan stroked my hair and hugged me tightly. I was glad she was in a better mood, and I felt a sense of inner satisfaction that it was because of me.

“You deserve a reward for being such a good little girl.” I suddenly shivered she was definitely going to turn on the vibrator in my diaper. Ooooh, yes, that would feel so good right now.

“Close your eyes, Haley. I’ll tell you when you can open ’em.” I could feel her fidgeting—she must be looking for her phone...

“You can open your eyes, Haley!” As soon as I opened my eyes, I saw something I never would have dared to imagine. Megan’s bare breasts were hanging right in front of my face.

“You know, sweetie, there’s no bond more intimate than when a mother breastfeeds her little girl, and I feel like that’s exactly what I need right now after everything that happened today. Open wide, sweetie.” Suddenly, I didn’t even know where to look! But I didn’t have much time to think; Megan pulled the pacifier out of my mouth and slowly began to push my head toward her breasts. I didn’t know what to do; by the time I tried to turn my head away, it was too late Megan’s nipple was already in my mouth.

Because my pacifier had been in my mouth for so long that I started sucking on Megan’s breast reflexively. She stroked my hair while I was sucking and I felt her body tremble from time to time and heard soft moans from her. I never felt so safe in my whole life. It was as if Megan really were my mommy and I really were her little girl. After a little while, Megan pulled her nipple out of my mouth. I was a little disappointed that this special feeling was already over. I looked up at her and saw that she was smiling.

“You’re a good little baby, Haley! See how nice being Mommy’s little girl is.” I nodded.

“You know, it would make me even happier if you called me Mommy. Just say ‘I love you, Mommy,’ and then I’ll breastfeed you from my other breast too.” I didn’t want her to stop, so I said it almost immediately.

“I love you, Mommy!!” Megan smiled.

“I love you too, Haley, little one. The next moment, her breast was already moving closer to my mouth, and I began to suckle with the greatest joy.

From that moment on, everything changed! I let go of all the expectations my parents had placed on me and gave up control. I let Megan take the lead, and I felt more free and happy than ever before. The days passed faster and faster, and day by day I became more and more the little baby Megan wanted me to be. I had less and less control over my bladder. I started to become incontinent; I didn’t even notice when I peed in my diaper. I spent most of my days in my nursery. Megan brought me more and more baby toys, and I played with them more and more often. Every night before bed, I took a bath with Megan, and I really loved every minute of it. One day, Megan walked into my nursery and came over to my crib.

“Good morning, Haley, sweetie! Today is a very special day but more for Mommy than for you. Guess what? Tonight is the camp competition where they’ll decide which team wins the prize of coming back to camp next year for free.” As I listened to Megan, my eyes widened. And suddenly I felt very sad. The summer couldn’t be over already—I couldn’t have to go home to my parents so soon. As I thought about this, I started crying without meaning it! Megan immediately wiped the tears from my face.

“It’s okay, Haley! Mommy’s going to win, don’t worry. But it would definitely help if you gave Mommy a big kiss!” She took my pacifier out of my mouth and lifted me into her arms. Still crying, I kissed her cheek and didn’t want her to ever put me down.

“Thank you, sweetie. Unfortunately, you can’t come with us. You know a little baby like you wouldn’t be safe there! But don’t worry, Mommy will be back soon. Until then, be a good girl and stay in your crib.” I looked up at Megan and nodded slowly.

“You’re such a good baby! ” she said and put me back in my crib. As I watched her walk out of my nursery, I started to cry. I didn’t want her to leave me alone, and I really didn’t want to go back to my old life!

As I lay alone in my crib, I could hear shouting and clapping coming into my room. I wanted to be there with the rest of the team. I didn’t want to be alone. As tears came to my eyes, I slowly felt my diaper getting wet. Since Mommy left, I’d peed myself three times. I lay there sucking on my pacifier until I finally fell asleep. In the morning, I woke up to loud celebrations. I could hear the girls talking. Soon the door to my nursery opened and the whole team came into the room. They gathered around my crib, led by Mommy, who was holding the trophy for first place.

“See, Haley… I told you we’d win! The others are here to say goodbye to you because camp is officially over,” she said. The rest of the team leaned closer to me and said goodbye one by one.

“You were a good girl, I hope we see you next year! ... I think Megan should change your diaper, Haley! ... You were a much better baby than the girls before you!” the girls said. Soon, only Mommy and I were left in the room. She took me out of my crib and carried me over to the changing table.

“You know, Haley, you’re a special little girl! You’re important to me, and I feel like I’m important to you too,” Megan said as she changed my dirty diaper.

“Honestly, I don’t want to give you back to your parents!” I looked up at Mommy in surprise, and tears came to my eyes. She wiped away my tears and laid me in her lap.

“I want you to be my little girl forever!” she said, and began to unhook her bra.

“Now you have a choice, Eva! Either you go back to your parents and we’ll never see each other again. Or you stay with me and be my little baby forever! If you want to come with me, start sucking on my breast. But if you don’t want to come with me, you can get up right now and leave the room!” My heart was pounding! I didn’t want to go back to my unhappy life. But what kind of life would I have as Megan’s baby forever? Confused, I looked up at Mommy and her breasts. Then I was overcome by an inner urge and started sucking! I didn’t even realize what was happening until Mommy started stroking my hair.

“You made the right decision, Haley! You’ll see, Mommy will give you everything a little baby could ever dream of.” I nursed at Mommy’s breasts for half an hour; I felt her love and peace in my soul. Mommy slowly pulled me away from her breasts and put her bra back on. I started crying because I couldn’t nurse on her breasts for any longer. But she quickly popped my pacifier into my mouth.

“It’s okay, sweetie! You’ll get more when we get back to Mommy’s house!” Megan put me back in my crib and went to pack her things. She came back soon after and packed plenty of diapers and a few toys for me for the trip. She picked me up in her arms, and we headed for the exit. On the way, we said goodbye to the rest of the team.

A black limousine was waiting for us in the camp parking lot. A driver in a suit opened the door for us, and I spotted an oversized baby seat in the back! My eyes widened. How did Mommy know I’d choose her? But it didn’t really matter anymore. Mommy strapped me into the car seat and kissed my forehead. Then, she handing the luggage to the driver, and sat down next to me in the back seat.

“That’s Oliver—he’s been my driver since I was fifteen. We’ll be leaving soon, sweetie!” Mommy said. As the limousine pulled away, I felt there was no turning back. I had sealed my fate. As I thought about this, I felt my diaper getting wet again. Mommy laughed and just said,

“Don’t worry, sweetie, Mommy will change your diaper as soon as we get home.”


© 2026 PetPanna · All rights reserved

PetPanna took the time to write this, and our authors really appreciate feedback — please take a moment to rate and review New Baby for the cheerleader captain.

Tap a star to rate

You might also like

Browse more ->

Novella

Retribution continues ....

5.0

Short

A Mother in her 40's going through a rebellious mid-life crisis which includes irresponsible alcoholism, gets taught the lesson of her lifetime by her teenage daughter's boyfriend.

5.0

Short

Set in the year 1991, submissive Julia is invited to the 18th birthday party of her rich, bratty cousin, Shannon. Shannon has always hated how poor and ugly Julia is. This is a wonderful opportunity for Shannon to humiliate Julia. Meanwhile, Julia has a secret fetish that would ruin her life if Shannon ever found out.

5.0